Ratree Likhitamnuay. Bithermal caloric stimulation test in patients with possible and definite meniere's disease . Master's Degree(Communication Disorders). Mahidol University. : Mahidol University, 2005.
Bithermal caloric stimulation test in patients with possible and definite meniere's disease
Abstract:
Meniere’s disease (MD) is a disorder of the inner ear associated with the presence of
endolymphatic hydrops. At present there is no single test that makes the diagnosis of MD. Caloric test has
been proven as useful in lateralizing the side of a vestibular lesion and in identifying disorders of the
labyrinth and the vestibular nerve. The reports were not found in generally available collective literature
studying the correlation between bithermal caloric stimulation test parameters and patients with possible, and
definite MD. The purposes of this study were to study the caloric responses in patients with possible and
definite MD, to compare the caloric responses between patients with possible and definite MD, and to study
the relationship among caloric parameters and duration of disease in patients with possible and definite MD.
In bithermal caloric test, each ear would be irrigated with water 125 cc.at 30oC and 44oC in all
patients. Possible MD group consisted of 5 males and 25 females, definite MD group consisted of 14 males
and 16 females. The mean ages, duration of disease, pure tone average (PTA) of right ears, PTA of left ears
were 44.33 years, 4.40 years, 17.06 and 17.24 dBHL, respectively for possible MD group and 45.30 years,
5.19 years, 39.58 and 40.94 dBHL, respectively for definite MD group. Patients reported the functional
level (at the level of 1, 2 and 3), tinnitus, aural fullness problems were 93.34%, 43.33% and 13.33%
respectively for possible MD group and 93.33%, 93.33% and 53.33%, respectively for definite MD groups.
The results for possible and definite MD group indicated that the means canal paresis (CP) and directional
preponderance (DP) value showed no significant difference between right and left values. The maximum
slow phase velocity (Vmax) showed no significant difference between the right and the left ears, the right
and the left beats. The Vmax of irrigation revealed that the warm irrigation was significantly weaker
response than the cool irrigation(p< 0.001). When comparing the results between both groups, the mean CP
and DP values of patients with definite MD group were significantly higher than those in possible MD
group (p< 0.05). No significant difference of mean Vmax for warm and cool water responses between
both groups. No relationship between caloric findings and duration of disease in both groups.
From the Vmax result, marked accentuation of the response to cold water irrigation was found in both
groups. The reasons might be due to patients with MD having had a change of the central nervous system
mechanism or the influence of pressure effects. The study of total CP and total DP indicators found that possible
MD could represent a low functional impairment of the vestibular organ. This finding showed that patients with
definite MD group might have more vestibular disturbance than possible MD group.
From this study, the comparison intergroups should be interpreted by using direct Vmax combination
with CP or DP indicators to make the diagnosis instead of the comparison by using the direct Vmax of warm or
cool irrigation alone; bithermal caloric testing should be used as a test battery in clinical evaluations of definite
MD and should be first conducted by warm water irrigation in order to reduce patients’ reaction to the test
because of MD patients marked accentuation of the response to cold water irrigation.