Kanayama, Akiri. Retail trade in Japanese signature seal (Hanko) and other ivory items in Japan and Thailand and its effect on elephant conservation . Master's Degree(Environmental Biology). Mahidol University. : Mahidol University, 2003.
Retail trade in Japanese signature seal (Hanko) and other ivory items in Japan and Thailand and its effect on elephant conservation
Abstract:
Beyond the imposition of the international trade restrictions on the
international ivory trade, decisions under CITES have had little effect on the domestic
ivory trade. In many parts of the world, the domestic markets are still active as usual
and without effective regulations. Today, the backbone of the trade is said to be a
signature seal called Hanko in Japanese and used in Japan and other eastern Asian
countries. In this study, it was investigated whether ivory Hanko in current demand in
Japan and by tourists, has effects on conservation.
In Japan, compared with the 1980s, the demand for ivory Hanko has decreased
as a result of economic recession. The study estimated 300,000-350,000 Hanko are
produced annually, requiring 15,000-53,000 kg of ivory, which can sustain only 1-4
years of domestic trade from the stock registered with government in 1999. The
domestic ivory market in Japan can therefore not possibly be sustained from the stock
recorded and indicates the presence of illegal ivory in the marketplace. Thus, ivory
Hanko in current demand in Japan is effecting the elephant conservation. In addition,
there was a significant number of ivory Hanko brought in Japan as souvenirs. Of an
estimate of 46,000 souvenir Hanko yearly brought to Japan, over 60% were from
China.
In Thailand, a total of 28,000 ivory pieces weighing 1,500 kg were seen in 104
souvenir shops in Bangkok. The main buyers are eastern Asian tourists and
businessmen from Japan, Korea, Taiwan and China. Hanko is said to be the most
popular ivory item. The estimated annual demand for ivory Hanko in Bangkok alone
is 4,000 while the volume of ivory obtained from domesticated elephants is 300-400
kg from which 5,000-6,700 Hanko can be produced. If ivory for Hanko production is
obtained from domesticated elephants, it can fulfill the present demand for ivory
Hanko in Bangkok.
The future of elephants is highly dependent on the effectiveness of regulation
in the domestic ivory market. The impact which the trade is having on the elephant
population would possibly be minimized with strict measurements. Both countries,
Japan and Thailand, require further improvement in control systems including the
registration of available stock and any means to distinguish legal from illegal ivory.